Overthinking – why we women tend to do it more often and how to change that

Überdenken

 

 

Do you keep thinking about whether it was the right decision to start your new job abroad? Is it hard to get your ex out of your head? When there’s a problem at work, do you keep going over it in your mind, wondering whether you expressed yourself well, or how serious the problem is?

At the same time, you might feel guilty because you haven’t reached out to your friends for days or spent too much time scrolling through feeds that don’t really interest you. You know you miss your friends but just can’t bring yourself to connect. If any of this sounds familiar, there’s a good chance you tend to overthink, which means spending a lot of time thinking about something without reaching a clear conclusion. You’re not alone; many others feel the same way.

In the following article, you will learn how to recognize overthinking and change it step by step, so you can experience more clarity, calm, and presence in your daily life.

What does overthinking mean, and how does it start?

Sadness, one of our five completely normal and everyday basic emotions, often triggers reflection in many women, unlike in men, who tend to distract themselves instead. Why am I sad? What is causing my sadness?

 

 

Reflection can quickly turn into rumination, a term psychology borrowed from biology. Cows chew their cud again and again. Similarly, when we overthink, we repeatedly go over “undigested” thoughts. Overthinking is a process where a person persistently thinks about their feelings and problems – this passive thinking takes over their attention. Studies have linked rumination to various mental health disorders. People with depression or anxiety tend to ruminate, which can contribute to the development, maintenance, or relapse of these conditions.

 
Asking about the causes of your own mood is, of course, important for creating lasting change and shaping a life that aligns with your values and needs. However, caution is needed here – “maximizing,” a decision-making style characterized by an exhaustive search for the best option, can quickly lead to overthinking, second-guessing, and regret, which can become exhausting over time.
 
Women are still influenced by socialization factors that tend to encourage a stronger sense of responsibility toward their environment and the people around them. The greater the sense of responsibility, the bolder the decisions, the more complex the life, and the bigger the heart and tendency to reflect, the more space there is for overthinking. There are countless ways and styles to live your life, which means there is also more to decide, question, and overthink. (I would argue this is more than ever before in our human history, although I’m not a historian.)
 
At the same time, a fulfilling life needs another magical ingredient: action. While you are wondering why you haven’t gotten up yet, or why you can’t seem to cook fresh meals regularly, or whether you should be living in a completely different country, or your mind is reminding you that you haven’t reached out to your friends in a long time, you feel less and less motivated and the chances that you will take action decrease.
 
The ability to reflect, question, weigh options, or ponder philosophical concepts like right and wrong is an incredible achievement of our human species. However, it comes with a cost. In addition to what has already been described, a Harvard study showed that we spend half of our waking time lost in thought. The study further reveals that dwelling on our thoughts instead of focusing on the present moment simply makes us unhappy.

 

So, does nothing really matter? How you can stop overthinking

 

How to tell the difference between overthinking and useful thinking

It is helpful to differentiate between when you are actually solving a problem in your mind and when you are just overthinking unproductively. Because overthinking often even feels productive. Problem solving differs from overthinking in that it involves fewer abstract thoughts and more concrete thoughts.

Abstract thoughts usually arise from questions like “Why?” For example, “Why did I procrastinate for so long?” or “Was the last breakup really the right decision?” These are examples of abstract thoughts that do not have a clear right answer. Concrete thoughts, on the other hand, relate to specific situations and experiences and focus more on questions starting with “What?” and “How?” This means planning and carrying out actions. For example, “What would be a small first step to get started?” or “What can I do now to feel better?”

Overthinking leads to nothing but more overthinking, especially when two factors are present: the content of your thoughts is highly distressing, or you are already feeling down. It is best to reflect on difficult life questions when you are in a better mood, perhaps while talking with a close friend or in a trusted setting with a psychologist.

Being present in the moment

Breaking free from overthinking is possible with practice. Another effective method is mindfulness. This is not only emphasized by traditional philosophical and religious approaches such as Buddhism but is also supported by scientific research. Mindfulness means the ability to focus on the present moment and to approach whatever you find there with openness and even kindness. Guided, classic breathing meditations have been shown to reduce the tendency to overthink.

You can also practice mindfulness in everyday life by giving your full attention to routine activities, such as drinking a cup of coffee. You can do the same regularly with your inner processes by briefly scanning your body throughout the day to notice what sensations are present. This is also a good first step toward making room for feelings, learning to observe what is happening in your body without judging it. This can also help you develop a more sensitive awareness of yourself and may allow you to recognize earlier when you are lost in thought, so that you can bring your attention back to the present moment.

 

Creating balance

Imagine you are lying on a surfboard. When you are going through a difficult phase in life, it is important to maintain balance in order to keep moving forward. If your left arm represents dealing with challenges or processing difficult experiences, and your right arm stands for distraction, you would just go in circles if you only used one arm to paddle. Therefore, a balance between facing challenges and allowing yourself distraction through enriching activities is necessary to keep moving forward.

 

You care deeply

 

Your tendency to overthink shows one thing above all: you care deeply about things. Yet, it only helps you to a limited extent and can fuel feelings of dissatisfaction, exhaustion, and anxiety.

If you find yourself overthinking, that is already a success because you have noticed what you are doing instead of sinking deeper into your thoughts. There is no reason for self-criticism even if your mind thinks otherwise. Instead, it is an opportunity to return to the here and now. If there is a problem that requires your attention, you can shift to active problem solving. Ask yourself what you can do in the present moment to make the best of the situation. That means focusing on actions that will bring you closer to the life you want right now.

I have created a five-week mini-series on the topic of overthinking that gives you a clear and easy-to-follow tip each week. It is completely free and you can of course unsubscribe anytime.

Your first small step away from self-doubt, sadness, and anxiety toward what truly matters. Sign up now.

Do you have any questions or comments? I look forward to hearing from you!
Love,

Nina

Sources

Finkel, D., Andel, R., & Pedersen, N. L. (2018). Gender differences in longitudinal trajectories of change in physical, social, and cognitive/sedentary leisure activities. The Journals of Gerontology: Series B, 73(8), 1491-1500.
 
Schwartz, B., Ward, A., Monterosso, J., Lyubomirsky, S., White, K., & Lehman, D. R. (2002). Maximizing versus satisficing: happiness is a matter of choice. Journal of personality and social psychology, 83(5), 1178.
 
Killingsworth, M. A., & Gilbert, D. T. (2010). A wandering mind is an unhappy mind. Science, 330(6006), 932-932.
 
Hawley, L. L., Schwartz, D., Bieling, P. J., Irving, J., Corcoran, K., Farb, N. A., … & Segal, Z. V. (2014). Mindfulness practice, rumination and clinical outcome in mindfulness-based treatment. Cognitive therapy and research, 38, 1-9.
 
Randenborgh, A. & Ehring, T. (2013). „Ich denke, also bin ich traurig“: Über die Folgen des Grübelns. The inquisitive mind, 1, 2013.

 

 

Schreibe einen Kommentar

Your email address will not be published. Erforderliche Felder sind mit * markiert

EN